Ponad 7000 publikacji medycznych!
Statystyki za 2021 rok:
odsłony: 8 805 378
Artykuły w Czytelni Medycznej o SARS-CoV-2/Covid-19

Poniżej zamieściliśmy fragment artykułu. Informacja nt. dostępu do pełnej treści artykułu tutaj
© Borgis - New Medicine 1/2016, s. 19-26 | DOI: 10.5604/14270994.1197176
*Ibolya Lipiennè Krèmer1, Melinda Rados2, Miklós Pálvölgyi3, Mihály Dió4, Judit Mèszáros5, Zsuzsanna Soósnè Kiss6
A highly demanding profession: midwifery. Do the midwives who provide sensitive support for birthing women feel satisfied and appreciated?
1Institute of Applied Health Sciences, Department of Clinical Studies in Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Faculty of Health Sciences, Semmelweis University Budapest, Hungary
Head of Faculty: Prof. Zoltán Zsolt Nagy, MD, PhD
2Institute of Basic Health Sciences, Department of Applied Psychology, Faculty of Health Sciences, Semmelweis University Budapest, Hungary
Head of Faculty: Prof. Zoltán Zsolt Nagy, MD, PhD
3Institute of Basic Health Sciences, Department of Social Sciences, Faculty of Health Sciences, Semmelweis University Budapest, Hungary
Head of Faculty: Prof. Zoltán Zsolt Nagy, MD, PhD
4Institute of Health Diagnostics, Department of Imaging and Medical Instrumentation, Faculty of Health Sciences, Semmelweis University Budapest, Hungary
Head of Faculty: Prof. Zoltán Zsolt Nagy, MD, PhD
5Institute of Applied Health Sciences, Department of Nursing, Faculty of Health Sciences, Semmelweis University Budapest, Hungary
Head of Faculty: Prof. Zoltán Zsolt Nagy, MD, PhD
6Institute for Health Promotion and Clinical Methodology, Department of Clinical Studies, Faculty of Health Sciences, Semmelweis University Budapest, Hungary
Head of Faculty: Prof. Zoltán Zsolt Nagy, MD, PhD
Summary
Introduction. Midwifery is a physically and emotionally exhausting profession. The type of calming, reassuring behaviour required from midwives when providing support for birthing women often takes its toll on their wellbeing. The large workloads they are requested to manage along with traumatic birth events might lead to compassion fatigue and burnout. Accompanying stress may result in feelings of being overloaded, as well as low levels of satisfaction and appreciation.
Aim. Our study aim was to discover the incidence and degree to which midwives are affected by high workloads in their work, as well as how satisfied and respected, appreciated they feel in their profession. Our additional goal was to see whether there is connection between burnout and the characteristics mentioned above.
Material and method. Our questionnaire collected information on socio-demographic data and health-related issues accompanied by work overload, satisfaction and appreciation. The final part was the Maslach Burnout Inventory (MBI). From the 283 completed and returned questionnaires 275 were finally included in the study. Data were analysed using the SPSS.
Results. Our results show that almost two thirds (65.9%) of the sample were satisfied either ‘mostly’ or ‘fully’, only every fourth midwife in our study (25.3%) felt appreciated in her everyday work. More than two thirds (69.1%) of midwives complain of being overloaded at work. Regarding the various factors of burnout: the factor of emotional exhaustion seemed to have the strongest relationship with all three perceived work characteristics; depersonalization and reduced personal accomplishment also proved to be strongly associated with satisfaction. We have discovered a strong relationship between satisfaction and appreciation (r = .333).
Conclusions. We conclude that seeing how essential midwives’ committed support is for birthing women and their families, midwives’ needs should be taken into consideration and the emotional aspects of midwives’ work should be kept in focus.
INTRODUCTION
Burnout is a common symptom occurring among health professionals, and midwives are unfortunately not an exception. The emotionally and physically exhausting work of midwives, i.e. providing support for women at the edge of their capacities is highly demanding. Large amounts of stress and high workloads contribute to high levels of exhaustion. It is difficult to live up to the tasks of the often conflicting principles of the hospital requirements and to be capable of building a trusting relationship with women during the birth process at the same time. There have been changes in midwifery during the past decades, which resulted in somewhat different tasks and methods in providing care. One reason might be that in many institutions technology has replaced midwifery skills carried out for centuries by midwives during births. The continuous change of the profession requirements might cause stress in the job. The latter, among other important factors, may cause midwives experiencing lower job satisfaction and burnout.
Definition of burnout
Burnout is defined as a syndrome of psychological problems arising as a result of work stress, mostly experienced by people working in healing and caring professions. According to Maslach and Jackson it can be described through three factors: emotional exhaustion, depersonalization and reduced personal accomplishment (1). The factor of emotional exhaustion refers to the feelings of being overextended and exhausted in an emotional sense. In connection with exhaustion the people experiencing burnout start to feel depersonalized from the people they work with. Depersonalization can be understood both as depersonalization of patients and of self, however. It manifests through general dislike, and a detached and callous – even dehumanized – attitude towards clients, who are perceived as energy drains or stressors. Being depersonalized of one’s self is connected to the last factor of reduced personal accomplishment. It is the negative self-perception of one’s competence and dissatisfaction with achievements at work. The Maslach Burnout Inventory (MBI) measures burnout using the aforementioned subscales.
Factors contributing to burnout
Various studies have been conducted in search for the factors which may influence midwives’ experienced stress and burnout. High workloads, lack of resources and low autonomy when caring for women appear to be among the most influential factors. In a study made in UK community midwifes and hospital midwives were compared regarding burnout (2). The Maslach Burnout Inventory showed high levels of emotional exhaustion among hospital midwives. The protective factors for community midwives were working in a team, working flexi-time and the supportive management. For higher burnout levels among hospital midwives low autonomy, role conflicts, high workloads, and bullying from colleagues and clients were signalled. Three key factors in order to stay with the job were: autonomy in occupation, social support and development of meaningful relationships with women. Unfortunately, the model of continuous midwifery care does not match the Hungarian way of care. It is separated into two professions: the midwife might have the contact with the pregnant women a few weeks before the birth term, but usually focuses on the actual birth event. The antenatal and postnatal visits at home are carried out by a special protective child’s nurse. Another study measured burnout among Swedish midwives and additionally raised the question of how satisfied midwives were in their profession and whether they have thought of leaving their profession (3). Burnout was measured using the Copenhagen Burnout Inventory (CBI), which is developed as an alternative inventory to the MBI. This inventory consists of three subscales: personal burnout, work burnout and client burnout. Personal burnout was found to be relatively high, nearly 40%, while the other two subscales were around 15%. Lack of staff and resources and stressful work environment were associated with burnout. Nearly one third of midwives have reported to have considered leaving their work. Additionally, the same study raises an important notion that however exhausting the type of emotional care might be, the trusting relationship with mothers appears to be rewarding for midwives. This proves to be an essential factor to stick with the job. Research done in Australia shows a somewhat similar pattern (4). The study made by Jordan and colleagues tried to determine the level of midwives’ burnout and the contributing and protective factors which might have an effect on burnout. Burnout was measured with CBI, and results show high burnout levels on the personal and work-related scale, but low levels on the patient-related scale. This probably means that midwives find it less stressful when they actually care for the women. Although we know how important the empathetic care midwives provide during supporting women during birth is (5, 6), midwives often find themselves caught in the middle between two, often contradictory roles; their role of a woman-centred caregiver and the role of a hospital worker. Another Australian study suggests that in today’s woman-focused care-giving, midwives themselves should be taken care of as well (7). In hospitals demand is escalating to do more work with less and less resources. They state that the ‘moral distress’ midwives experience when doing their job is very high, because there is always the dilemma of being able to provide affectionate, reassuring, gentle care where women feel empowered and safe arising from the relationship with women and, on the other hand, to be able to obey the sometimes impersonal hospital practice and rules where monitoring and various interventions are ‘overused’. The continuous shortages of skilled birth midwives cause a problem as well.
Another common finding is that the midwives’ age and the years of experience within the profession are negatively correlated with burnout (3, 4). This means that increasing age and years spent in the profession are usually associated with lower burnout scores. Jordan et al. have come to the conclusion that midwives younger than 35 were 2.4 times more likely to suffer from burnout than participants over 35 years of age (4). In the same study other personal variables found to be associated with burnout levels were being single and having no children. Participants with more than 10 years spent in the profession scored high in the personal, work and client domains of the CBI. Interestingly, midwives who have spent more than 20 years in the profession scored high in the first two domains, but no one was identified as suffering from burnout in the client domain. Midwives who were not having any recreation leave or sick leave within the previous three months before the date of the study were 2.5 more likely to experience burnout. A possible explanation for less midwives experiencing burnout might be that caregivers over 35 might have gained more competency and practical skills through the large amount of various experiences, which might help them overcome stress more effectively (8). Lipiennè et al. previous study on the topic does not verify this in the Hungarian context (9). We have measured burnout in the Hungarian midwife population using the Maslach Burnout Inventory. Regarding the various factors of burnout, midwives scored high on the MBI, namely 23% on the emotional exhaustion scale and 33% on the depersonalisation scale. The highest percentage (36%) was found on the reduced personal accomplishment scale. In other words, it can be stated that nearly every third midwife in Hungary experiences high burnout. Furthermore, we were interested to see whether there is connection between the age of midwives and the burnout scores. According to our findings the MBI burnout scores were not related to age, burnout appeared to be equally strong among midwives of all age groups.
Fear of litigation is also a stressor that has been linked to burnout and midwives’ well-being (10). As Lipiennè et al. suggest in their earlier article, midwives in Hungary probably have lower responsibility while providing care compared to many other countries (9). Usually all interventions are carried out by doctors, or under their supervision, even the anaesthetic and analgesic measures. At the same time, midwives are usually in charge to estimate when the time comes to call the gynaecologist doctor. Due to these differences the fear of litigation contributes to a lower extent to the stress encountered at work. On the other hand, according to research, lower autonomy at work contributes to experience burnout (2).
As previously stated, burnout is most common with health professionals and professions which require high levels of community engagement. As a result, people are more likely to suffer from any health related problems (11). Professionals working in the health sector are usually expected to be able to cope with the challenges of the daily work of caring for patients. Hunter suggests that the high level emotional work provided by midwives stays professionally unacknowledged and this is a key element which might make them internalise the negative emotions from any source as their own personal dilemmas and failings (12). A Dutch study measured burnout among community midwives who, according to the Dutch model, provide care during births at the home of women in up to 50 percent of their cases (13). According to the findings of the study, midwives who carried out a higher percentage of home births showed lower depersonalisation on the MBI scale. This was associated with those who have more passive coping styles, however. Another important finding of the study is that midwives receiving more social support were less emotionally exhausted and depersonalised, and felt higher personal accomplishment. Social support between people is present when a human being recognises another person’s identity, values that person and sometimes even helps him or her. In other words, it is the perceived support from significant others. According to this, midwives shall cope better with the high workloads and other problematic issues when they feel supported by their colleagues. In research done by Mollart et al., if we take a closer look at the personal accomplishment factor of the MBI, midwives who worked in mixed day and night shift had the lowest feelings of personal accomplishment (8). This has shown to have an impact on their belief to deal effectively with clients’ problems. Those having only night duty felt at least that they have the capacity to positively influence other people through their work. The same group scored poorly on the depersonalisation scale, stating that they ‘do not really care’ what happens to clients. This is contradictory to the type of empathetic and compassionate care, which is a key element of the midwifery profession.
Research has been conducted to identify the type of health-related aspects of the midwives’ profession. Work-related stress and the possibility for vicarious trauma are relevant issues which need to be dealt with. In a Slovak study trying to determine the most common stressors Banovcinova and Baskova have found that death and dying of patients were reported as the most stressful factor (14). The next most influential stressing factor was conflict with a superior, usually a doctor, whereas the conflict with co-workers was perceived as contributing only to a lower extent to work stress. Stressors might have alternative sources in the work environment. As part of an initiative, midwives who provide continuous care in some local health services in Australia and the United Kingdom, were given the task to screen mothers for potential psychosocial risks, such as domestic violence, depression and child protection issues at the first antenatal visit (11, 15, 16). Midwives have reported difficulties coping with issues which have arisen. They felt helpless, not being able to offer effective help, and high emotional stress was experienced. Professional supervision which, unfortunately, was not offered simultaneously would have been necessary to overcome this high emotional impact. Mollart et al., investigating the impact of structured antenatal psychosocial assessment on midwives’ emotional wellbeing, who carried out focus group interviews discovered that midwives have difficulty handling the disclosure of trauma, and lack ability to manage their own emotion (11). Midwives in Hungary do not provide care at antenatal visits, since this is arranged by the protective child’s nurse of the district, where the mother lives. Midwives usually meet the pregnant women in the hospital or another consulting-room only a few times for fetal non-stress test (NST) before the actual date of birth. Despite that, midwives are usually well aware of women’s fears and of the potential trauma which mothers experienced during a previous birth. They have to keep all this in mind when supporting birthing mothers. Dealing with traumatic birth events as stressors may need to be acknowledged by the management at each birth unit.
AIM
This study is part of a broader study trying to determine the burnout level of the Hungarian midwife population and to reveal whether it can be matched with any socio-demographic data and other health-related issues (9). The current study aims to investigate the satisfaction level of midwives, along with how overloaded they feel in their work. Additionally, we are interested in the level of appreciation midwives perceive during their care for women. Furthermore, we would like to see whether levels of satisfaction, feelings of work overload and perceived appreciation can be matched with the burnout scores.
MATERIAL AND METHODS

Powyżej zamieściliśmy fragment artykułu, do którego możesz uzyskać pełny dostęp.
Mam kod dostępu
  • Aby uzyskać płatny dostęp do pełnej treści powyższego artykułu albo wszystkich artykułów (w zależności od wybranej opcji), należy wprowadzić kod.
  • Wprowadzając kod, akceptują Państwo treść Regulaminu oraz potwierdzają zapoznanie się z nim.
  • Aby kupić kod proszę skorzystać z jednej z poniższych opcji.

Opcja #1

19

Wybieram
  • dostęp do tego artykułu
  • dostęp na 7 dni

uzyskany kod musi być wprowadzony na stronie artykułu, do którego został wykupiony

Opcja #2

49

Wybieram
  • dostęp do tego i pozostałych ponad 7000 artykułów
  • dostęp na 30 dni
  • najpopularniejsza opcja

Opcja #3

119

Wybieram
  • dostęp do tego i pozostałych ponad 7000 artykułów
  • dostęp na 90 dni
  • oszczędzasz 28 zł
Piśmiennictwo
1. Maslach C, Jackson SE: Maslach Burnout Inventory. 2nd ed. Consulting Psychologists Press, Palo Alto, California 1986. 2. Yoshida Y, Sandall J: Occupational burnout and work factors in community and hospital midwives: A survey analysis. Midwifery 2013; 29: 921-926. 3. Hildingsson I, Westlund K, Wiklund I: Burnout in Swedish midwives. Sexual & Reproductive Healthcare 2013; 4: 87-91. 4. Jordan K, Fenwick J, Slavin V et al.: Level of burnout in a small population of Australian midwives. Women and Birth 2013; 26: 125-132. 5. Bryanton J, Fraser-Davey H, Sullivan P: Women’s Perceptions of Nursing Support during Labor. Journal of Obstetric, Gynecologic & Neonatal Nursing 1994; 23(8): 638-644. 6. Rados M, Kovács E, Mèszáros J: Intimacy and privacy during childbirth. A pilot-study testing a new self-developed questionnaire: the Childbirth Intimacy and Privacy Scale (CIPS). New Medicine 2015; 19(1): 16-24. 7. Reiger K, Lane K: ‘How can we go on caring when nobody here cares about us?’. Australian public maternity units as contested care sites. Women and Birth 2013; 26: 133-137. 8. Mollart L, Skinner VM, Newing C, Foureur M: Factors that may influence midwives work-related stress and burnout. Women and Birth 2013; 26: 26-32. 9. Lipiennè Krèmer I, Dió M, Mèszáros J: Burn-out Research Among Midwives. New Medicine 2014; 28 (4): 146-150. 10. Hood L, Fenwick J, Butt J: A story of scrutiny and fear: Australian midwives’ experiences of an external review of obstetric services, being involved with litigation and the impact on clinical practice. Midwifery 2010; 26(3): 267-268. 11. Mollart L, Newing C, Foureur M: Midwives’ emotional wellbeing: Impact of conducting a Structured Antenatal Psychosocial Assessment (SAPSA). Women and Birth 2009; 22: 82-88. 12. Hunter B: Conflicting ideologies as a source of emotion work in midwifery. Midwifery 2004; 20: 261-272. 13. Bakker RHC, Groenewegen PP, Jabaaij L et al.: ‘Burnout’ among Dutch midwives. Midwifery 1996; 12: 174-181. 14. Banovcinova L, Baskova M: Sources of work-related stress and their effect on burnout in midwifery. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences 2014; 132: 248-254. 15. McCosker-Howard H, Kain V, Anderson D, Webster J: The impact on midwives of undertaking screening for domestic violence – focus group findings. Birth Issues 2005; 14(2): 49-56. 16. Mezey G, Bacchus L, Haworth A, Bewley S: Midwives’ perceptions and experiences of routine enquiry for domestic violence. British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology 2003; 110: 744-753.
otrzymano: 2016-01-13
zaakceptowano do druku: 2016-02-08

Adres do korespondencji:
*Ibolya Lipiennè Krèmer
Department of Clinical Studies in Obstetrics and Gynaecology Faculty of Health Sciences Semmelweis University
1088 Budapest, Vas ut 17, Hungary
tel.: +36 1-486-48-90
e-mail: lipienne@se-etk.hu

New Medicine 1/2016
Strona internetowa czasopisma New Medicine