© Borgis - New Medicine 4/2003, s. 97-99
Radoslaw Owczuk1, Magdalena Anna Wujtewicz1, Wioletta Sawicka1, Maria Wujtewicz1, Arkadiusz Piankowski1, Barbara Kwiecinska1, Agnieszka Markul2, Ewa Januszewska-Michalak2, Iwona Bednarska-Zytko3, Barbara Skoczylas-Stoba3, Irena Burdak4
Analysis of effective out-of-hospital resuscitations in the elderly
1 Department of Anaesthesia and Intensive Care, Medical University of Gdansk, Poland
Head: Maria Wujtewicz, MD, PhD
2 Department of Anaesthesia and Intensive Care, St. Adalbert´s Specialist Hospital, Gdansk, Poland
Head: Ewa Januszewska-Michalak, MD
3 Department of Anaesthesia and Intensive Care, N. Copernicus´ Regional Specialist Hospital,
Head: Barbara Skoczylas-Stoba, MD, PhD
4 Department of Anaesthesia and Intensive Care, Railway Hospital, Gdansk
Head: Irena Burdak, MD
In this paper we present the results of a questionnaire study concerning out-of-hospital resuscitations performed on the elderly (> 70 years of age). Included were 69 cases of cardiac arrest. The mean patient age was 74.6 yrs; men were more numerous than women (60.9% vs. 39.1%). The most common cause of circulation arrest was ventricular fibrillation. We analysed the patients´ state on their admission to hospital, as well as the outcomes. Most patients died a short time after admission to hospital. Of the analysed patients 7,2% survived for a period longer than 12 months.
Cardiac arrest in elderly persons is often perceived as a natural ending of their lives, particularly in those with chronic ailments. Resuscitating these patients may be considered as a treatment which is unnecessary or is fated to fail. Previous reports on cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) in the geriatric population have presented different opinions from those included in the current standards and guidelines on resuscitation (1). This policy causes many physicians to initiate the reanimation of elderly patients very reluctantly. However, the DNR "do not resuscitate” rule, which is in force in some countries, concerns only selected cases of hospitalised patients, and may be applied after a scrupulous analysis of all the pros and cons of reanimation by a special committee. In no case does rule apply this to out-of-hospital reanimations, where another rule ("first rescue, then ask”) should be obeyed (2).
Current publications concerning restrictions on resuscitation include only such conditions as decapitation, body charring or decay, or the presence of rigor mortis, but do not include the patient´s age (3, 4). The aforementioned ”unwillingness” to start resuscitating elderly persons with cardiac arrest (CA) may also be caused by the rescuers´ opinions on whether or not the short– and long-term CPR outcomes in these patients will be satisfactory. Analysis of references published in English does not support these doubts univocally, and there are no publications from Polish sources. The specificity of the Polish healthcare system, due to society´s low level of education on basic (non-instrumental) life support, and to the ever-developing medical rescue system, may result in different findings from those concerning more highly-developed countries. Therefore, analysis was covered out-of-hospital cardiopulmonary resuscitations which were judged effective in persons of over 70 years of age.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
The analysis included cases of cardiac arrest and effective cardiopulmonary resuscitation in out-of-hospital environments in persons of over 70 years, in whom prehospital aid was given by reanimation teams (R teams) from the Regional Emergency Medical Service Station in Gdańsk.
First, the report books of the EMS R teams from 1997 to 2001 were analysed. Resuscitation was treated as effective if the patient was transported and admitted to a hospital emergency department. Secondly, study questionnaires were sent to departments of intensive care in 4 hospitals.
Seventy-one replies to questionnaires were obtained. Two cases of isolated respiratory arrest were excluded; and so 69 cases of cardiac arrest in out-of-hospital environments were for analysed.
Two scales were included in the questionnaire: the Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS), and the five-gradelarge Cerebral Performance Category (CPC) (according to 5).
The analysis included 69 questionnaires, 27 of which concerned women (39.1%), and 42 men (60.9%). The mean age in the studied population was 74.61 years (range of 70-91 yrs; std 4.84). Age of women ranged from 70 to 91 yrs, and mean age was 74.96 yrs (SD 5.71; median 74 yrs). Men´s age ranged from 70 to 89 yrs with mean value of 74.38 yrs (SD 4.24; median 74 yrs). No statistically significant difference was found between the mean ages of the men and women (p = 0.629).
In 52 cases the time of cardiac arrest was established, as shown in fig. 1.
Fig. 1. Incidents of cardiac arrest by time of day.
In 36 patients cardiac arrest occurred at home (52.1%), in 9 persons it happened in the street, one patient had CA in church and another one in a bank. No cases of cardiac arrest in a workplace were noted, and in 22 cases the environment where CA and resuscitation took place could not be stated.
With the aid of each patient´s medical documentation, the following ailments from before the CA incident were found: ischaemic heart disease – 40 cases; history of myocardial infarction – 21; arterial hypertension – 21; chronic circulatory insufficiency – 20; brain stroke/hemiparesis – 9; bronchial asthma/COPD – 7; diabetes mellitus – 14; disturbances of cerebral circulation – 7. Four patients suffered from neoplastic disease; in two of them the disease was disseminated, and two were cured of cancer. One patient had been previously resuscitated 13 months before (discharged from hospital with a CPC score of 1).
The most frequent pathogenic cause of cardiac was ventricular fibrillation (VF), observed in 33 cases altogether. Asystole occurred in 9 cases, and bradyasystole in 4 cases. No cases of pulseless electrical activity (PEA) or pulseless ventricular tachycardia (PVT) were observed. In 29 cases the medical documentation contained no remarks on the mechanisms of patients´ cardiac arrest! Before transportation to hospital the majority of the patients (95.6%) were intubated. Three persons had their airways unprotected, and in two of them respiration was inefficient.
Adrenalin was the most frequently administered drug (40 documented cases), whilst atropine was administered in 21 cases, lignocaine in 17 cases, and bretylium in 2 cases of VF; no case of amiodarone administration was found. Bicarbonate solution was administered in 19 patients, and 24 patients were treated with corticosteroids (dexamethasone or hydrocortisone). Other applied medication included frusemide (7 patients), aminophylline (one patient), verapamil (one patient), digoxin (one patient), and drip infusion of dopamine (8 patients) or dobutamine (2 patients). Electrical defibrillation was performed on 29 patients; in two of them this was the only method of treatment which permitted the restoration of efficient circulation.
On admission to emergency departments 18 patients (26.1%) showed no vital signs; in each case CPR was initiated in the emergency department. CPR was effective in 5 cases, and in 13 cases death in the emergency department was recorded.
Vital signs on admission were observed in 51 patients, breathing was evaluated as efficient in 7 patients (13.7%), and circulation was efficient in 26 patients (50.98%). The consciousness of 3 persons was described as "complete”. In 46 persons consciousness was assessed by means of the GCS; scores are presented in fig. 2.
Fig. 2. Patient assessment by the Glasgow Coma Scale on admission to emergency departments.
ECG charts showed ventricular and supraventricular extrasystole (12 and 2 patients, respectively), atrial fibrillation (9 patients), LBBB in 6 patients, RBBB in one patient. The ST interval was lowered in 8 cases, and Pardee´s wave was present in 6 cases.
Powyżej zamieściliśmy fragment artykułu, do którego możesz uzyskać pełny dostęp.
Płatny dostęp tylko do jednego, POWYŻSZEGO artykułu w Czytelni Medycznej
(uzyskany kod musi być wprowadzony na stronie artykułu, do którego został wykupiony)
Płatny dostęp do wszystkich zasobów Czytelni Medycznej